Medicinal plants may be a key to understanding other cultures
Irene Teixidor-Toneu has designed a methodology for comparing herbal medicine across societies. This can also be used to understand the transfer of cultural traditions.
“I did a thorough documentation of the natural remedies, mostly plants, used by the Amazigh people in the High Atlas. Then, I studied how modernization in its various forms influences the use of plants,” explains Irene Teixidor-Toneu.
“To summarize, there is a change in the use of substances, since people are open to medication prescribed by the doctor. At the same time, traditional knowledge and beliefs concerning plant use are kept alive, although traditions also change over time.”
Having spent almost a year in the Moroccan High Atlas mountains, ethnobotanist Irene Teixidor-Toneu finished her PhD on the use of medicinal plants in Amazigh (Berber) villages.
Her scientific article, describing the methodology, was published in the October issue of the journal Nature Plants. She is currently a postdoctoral fellow at the Natural History Museum of the University of Oslo, where her methods will be applied to map the use of medicinal plants in Scandinavia from Viking times until today, in a project that was launched in November 2018.
Modern or traditional medicine?
Teixidor-Toneu grew up in a rural village in the central part of Catalonia, in the north-eastern corner of Spain, and studied at the University of Barcelona. She holds a Master in oceanography. She enjoyed especially the ecology part of her studies, and was somewhat doubtful as to her academic career, since she could not see herself as a future oceanographer.
Then, an opportunity turned up at the University of Reading in the UK. A PhD project in ethnobotany was announced. Teixidor-Toneu applied, and was accepted – much to her own astonishment.
“I grew up in a family that uses local herbs. I did several collaborative projects with the botanical department during my studies, and I also assisted PhD students in botany at the University of Barcelona. In short, that was my background for sending the application to Reading.”
Her PhD dissertation was devoted to the transmission of knowledge about medicinal plants used by a defined group of people. These were some of the basic questions Teixidor-Toneu studied:
- Why are certain plants selected for medical use?
- How are they used?
- How does usage change over time?
If you were to ask a pharmacist, one obvious explanation to why certain plants are used, is that they contain phytochemicals. Phytochemicals are compounds developed in order help plants thrive or fight competitors, predators, or pathogens. Many phytochemicals have therapeutic effects.
However, there is always a combination of reasons why a plant is selected for use, according to Teixidor-Toneu.
Faith and lore
Ethnobiology is defined as the interdisciplinary study of how human cultures interact with and use their native plants and animals. Ethnobotany is defined as the plant lore of indigenous cultures, also the systematic study of such lore.
Irene Teixidor-Toneu explains:
“In studies of plant diversity and conservation, there are a lot of ecological models that don’t take people into account at all. If you think of the vegetation in the Mediterranean area, as an example, nothing makes sense if you don’t consider humans and their influence. After all, the region has been shaped and developed by man for millennia.”
From colouring to food
Most of us probably think of food, spice and medicine, when the subject of plant use is brought up. However, there is a multitude of historic and present practices. Like fumigation.
Fumigation is the physical process of burning and making smoke out of a plant. This can be ritual or medical or a combination of both. It can be done to clean out a dirty room, to remove fleas and ticks and other insects. In Morocco, the Amazigh burn plant that are rich in resins in order to clean the stables for their animals.
Other uses vary from producing and dyeing textiles, making furniture and utensils, construction of houses to providing fodder and veterinary medicine.
The interdisciplinary aspect is one reason why Irene Teixidor-Toneu finds ethnobotany so fascinating:
”There has been a patchwork of approaches and methods because people from different backgrounds have come together, with no common theoretical framework. Researchers from the humanities and natural scientists often have different approaches. In recent years, we have seen some articles trying to unite and define ethnobiology as one discipline, but there are still many ways to regard the interaction of people and plants.”
Constructing family trees
Teixidor-Toneu has provided a significant contribution through her perspective article recently published in Nature Plants, with co-authors Fiona Jordan (evolutionary anthropologist, University of Bristol) and Julie A. Hawkins (phylogenetist, University of Reading).
Basically, it is a summary of the theoretical analysis for her PhD work. The article proposes a framework to study plant uses. This framework uses phylogenetic comparative methods applied to anthropological data, which involves – to put it simply - the construction of language family trees.
For some time, it has been used by anthropologists to gain understanding of the evolution of political, religious, social and material culture. It has not previously been applied to plant use, as pointed out by the editor of Nature Plants in the editorial:
“Normally we associate the use of (…) phylogenetic analyses to determine the relationships between species and groups of organisms, tracing their evolution back to putative common ancestors. (…) Teixidor-Toneu et al. have applied comparative phylogenetic methods, not to plants themselves but to the medicinal roles to which they have been put. Even within ethnobotany this is not a common approach, but the ability to use multiple types of data can produce robust and detailed information about how cultural information is transmitted”
Medicinal plants are of special interest because of their role in maintaining people’s health. Phylogenetic comparative methods can enable researchers to study the diversity of medicinal plant applications across cultures, and also to infer changes in plant use over time.
These methods can be applied to single medicinal plants as well as the entire set of plants used by a culture for medicine, known as a pharmacopoeia.
Plants and cultural knowledge are both endangered
“I think the main significance of our paper is that it opens up new opportunities for studying plant use. At the moment, we are well aware that that biodiversity is threatened. Cultural diversity and traditional lifestyles are also threatened. In other words, many plants as well as the knowledge about how to use them, are endangered. Therefore, there is an urgent need to understand how various threatening factors interact and how use and knowledge change over time,” Irene Teixidor-Toneu explains, and adds:
“We are trying to understand plant use across cultures. The first thing we need to understand is how cultures are related. We use phylogeny models, or pedigrees, to trace relationships between people and cultures, based on language similarities.”
“Having traced evolutionary relationships between cultures, we can identify and try to understand the ways plants are used in different cultures. Within this framework we can also study how uses change, and it can be linked to geographical models. So, we end up with what we could call a biocultural geography.”
The PhD project on plant use at the University of Reading was part of a Marie-Curie Innovative Training Network project, funded by the European Commission. Through this European ITN network of projects, Irene Teixidor-Toneu, got to know botanists at the Natural History Museum of the University of Oslo. These relationships, combined with personal reasons, made her move to Oslo, where she is now working as a postdoctoral researcher on a large inter-disciplinary project that applies the comparative phylogenetic methods described in her Nature Plants article.
The scientific article:
More on Titan.uio.no:
Mest lest siste syv dager
Nyheter fra andre
De store verdenshavene er kjent for folk flest. Mindre kjent er selve havbunnen – og at det hele tiden avsettes sedimenter der.
Hva får en molekylærbiolog til å sende en spørreundersøkelse om mobbing på arbeidsplassen til 5000 personer? Og hvorfor får han tilsendt spyttprøver fra 1200 av dem?
Denne gjengen undersøker hvordan helsetjenestene fungerer i dag og hvordan de kan bli bedre. Håpet deres er å få politikere og helsebyråkrater til å tenke nytt.
– Hvis folk spør meg, sier jeg at det er livsvitenskap hvis det har med helse, miljø og bærekraft å gjøre, sier Carl Henrik Gørbitz. Han er leder for Universitetet i Oslos største faglige satsing noensinne, på nettopp livsvitenskap.